Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Sam Rittenberg's avatar

While one can never, ever, ever dismiss the effect of domestic politics on even the weightiest of presidential decisions, in this case, I think that the historical thread that you suggest is one of the less important of the many variables that affected the decision made by each the three men. In the case of Kennedy – an international geopolitical environment that both produced and resulted in Soviet encroachment in Germany and Cuba, Kennedy having been “pushed around” by Khrushchev in Vienna, and the resumption of Soviet nuclear testing probably had a much more direct influence on his decision. Johnson certainly could have had politics on his mind but was likely much more concerned about his place in history, “I won’t be the first American president to lose a war”. In Biden’s case, I would argue that the debacle in Afghanistan and the PRC eyeing Taiwan were the more immediate influences. But all of this takes a back seat to the Fat Bastard reference! Thanks for that! Next, “molé mole, mole!”

Expand full comment
R.A. Watman (Anne)'s avatar

Do you think there’s any chance that the botched Afghanistan withdrawal has anything to do with Biden’s stance on Ukraine? I’m not dismissing the relationship between Democrats and Russia, and I know Trump was ready to get troops out of Afghanistan, too. But, Biden has certainly made himself look tough when it comes to Russia. (Although, I personally worry that he’s not doing enough.)

Expand full comment
5 more comments...

No posts